Orders open Monday to Wednesday. Baked Thursday. Delivered Friday and Saturday.

Fresh from our oven

Cookies worth pleading for.

Artisanal cookies, baked to order and delivered fresh each week.

Order cookies

Featured cookies

View all flavors

Made for sharing

Build your cookie box

Pick any mix of flavors. Everything is baked together and delivered fresh on your day.

Build your box

Shop by type

Baked once a week, to order.

Nothing sits on a shelf. You order in the weekly window, we bake, and we deliver fresh. Read how ordering works.

Follow alongSee each week’s bakes and flavors on Instagram.

@the.fifthamendment

Gallery

Fresh from the oven. Follow us on Instagram for each week’s bakes.

Menu

Everything we bake, by type. Tap any item to read about it.

Make it yoursMost of what we bake can be made to suit your diet, and every cookie comes in your choice of format. You choose for each piece when you order.

Cookie formats

ClassicCookie cupCookie tin
Classic
Cookie cup
Cookie tin

Dietary options

Gluten-freeNut-freeLactose-freeSugar-freeProtein

Nut-free isn’t available on items made with nuts. Some options carry an extra charge, confirmed with your order. Have an allergy? Tell us in your order notes.

Start an order

Order

Orders open Monday to Wednesday. Choose your flavors, add your details and send your order. Tap + on any item to pick your options.

Nothing added yet

Your order

We confirm every order by message before baking. Prefer Instagram? and send it to @the.fifthamendment.

Our story

Rythm Gupta

It started with a stolen cookie and a standoff. We were sitting around my friend’s living room in Brisbane, half-watching Harvey Specter tear an opposing counsel apart on an episode of Suits. The host walked in, stared at the empty plate on the table, and demanded to know who took the last cookie. Nobody moved. The silence was heavy. Looking at the screen, the only legal defense that made sense flashed into my head: Plead the fifth. Do not incriminate yourself. That was the exact moment The Fifth Amendment was born. It is a brand built on the fundamental truth that when a bake is truly that good, you take the last piece and you absolutely do not apologize for it.

But a sharp name means nothing without the execution to back it up. The real fire for this craft didn’t come from a television show; it is in the blood. I grew up watching my mother command the kitchen. She has been baking for twenty years, operating as an uncompromising professional for more than a decade. There were no shortcuts in her house, no skipped steps, and no accepted failures. You respected the ingredients, and you executed the technique. Just by standing beside her, absorbing that relentless discipline and the exact science of her process, the obsession took hold of me. I didn’t just learn how to fold dough; I learned the standard required to make something unforgettable.

Today, The Fifth Amendment takes that generational discipline and applies it to a modern, heavy-hitting flavor lineup. We don’t do basic, and we don’t do average. We bake unapologetic, premium profiles designed for people who know exactly what they want.

Rythm Gupta
Start an order

Help

Answers to the questions we hear most.

How does ordering work?

Choose your flavors on the Order page, pick a delivery day and send us the order on Instagram. We confirm by message, bake on Thursday and deliver on your day.

When can I order?

Orders open Monday to Wednesday each week. Anything placed after that goes into the following week’s bake.

When do you deliver?

We deliver on Friday and Saturday. You choose your day when you order.

How do I pay?

We confirm your order by message and share payment details then.

Still need help?Message us on Instagram and we will reply.

@the.fifthamendment

Reviews

What our customers say about their orders.

No reviews here yet. Tried our cookies? Tell us what you thought on Instagram.

Share your review