Fresh from our oven

Cookies worth pleading for.

Artisanal cookies, baked to order in Brisbane and delivered fresh each week.

Order cookies

Featured cookies

View all flavors

Exhibit A

The Fifth Amendment

/ðə fɪfθ əˈmɛndmənt/ noun

  1. In law. The part of the United States Constitution that says nobody can be forced to be a witness against themselves. That’s why, in courtroom dramas, someone under pressure says “I plead the fifth”: they’re using their right to stay silent.
  2. In Brisbane. An artisanal bakery whose cookies are worth that silence. When someone asks who took the last one, you don’t confess. You plead the fifth.

Warning: Don’t leave the crumbs on your shirt.

How a missing cookie became a bakery

Made for sharing

Build your cookie box

Pick any mix of flavors. Everything is baked together and delivered fresh on your day.

Build your box

Shop by type

Brisbane’s made-to-order cookie bakery

Artisanal cookies, baked in Brisbane

The Fifth Amendment is a small-batch, made-to-order bakery in Brisbane, Queensland. We bake thick, gourmet stuffed cookies in 30 flavours, from Golden Saffron & Cardamom Core to Miso Sesame, alongside cakes and breads. Nothing is made ahead or kept on a shelf: you order Monday to Wednesday, we bake on Thursday, and we deliver fresh on Friday and Saturday.

  • 30 cookie flavoursStuffed centres, spice and floral, chocolate, savoury and the classics.
  • Made your wayClassic, cookie cup or cookie tin, with gluten-free, nut-free, lactose-free, sugar-free and protein options.
  • Boxes and giftsBuild a box of 6 or 12, send it as a gift with a note card, or order for your workplace.
  • One-week specialsA new limited cookie, cake and bread every week, never repeated.

Baked once a week, to order.

Nothing sits on a shelf. You order in the weekly window, we bake, and we deliver fresh. Read how ordering works.

Follow alongSee each week’s bakes and flavors on Instagram.

@the.fifthamendment

Gallery

Fresh from the oven. Follow us on Instagram for each week’s bakes.

Our menu

Every cookie, cake and bread we bake in Brisbane, by type. Tap any item to hear its case.

Make it yoursMost of what we bake can be made to suit your diet, and every cookie comes in your choice of format. You choose for each piece when you order.

Cookie formats

ClassicCookie cupCookie tin
Classic
Cookie cup
Cookie tin

Dietary options

Gluten-freeNut-freeLactose-freeSugar-freeProtein

Nut-free isn’t available on items made with nuts. Some options carry an extra charge, confirmed with your order. Have an allergy? Tell us in your order notes.

Corporate ordersOrdering for your office, clients or an event? For corporate orders, contact us using our enquiry form.
Enquire now

Start an order

Order cookies online

Orders open Monday to Wednesday. Choose your flavors, add your details and send your order. Tap + on any item to pick your options.

Corporate or large order? Contact us using our enquiry form.

Build your own boxChoose a box of 6 or 12 and fill it with any cookies you like.
Nothing added yet

Your order

Sign in to save your details, track your orders and earn points: 1 point for every $10 you spend, worth $1 each. You can also order as a guest.

Order summary

We confirm every order by message before baking. Prefer Instagram? and send it to @the.fifthamendment.

Our story

plead the fifth (phrase): to refuse to answer a question that might get you in trouble, a right protected by the Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution. Also: the only sensible reply when someone asks who ate the last cookie.
Rythm Gupta

It started with a stolen cookie and a standoff. We were sitting around my friend’s living room in Brisbane, half-watching Harvey Specter tear an opposing counsel apart on an episode of Suits. The host walked in, stared at the empty plate on the table, and demanded to know who took the last cookie. Nobody moved. The silence was heavy. Looking at the screen, the only legal defense that made sense flashed into my head: Plead the fifth. Do not incriminate yourself. That was the exact moment The Fifth Amendment was born. It is a brand built on the fundamental truth that when a bake is truly that good, you take the last piece and you absolutely do not apologize for it.

But a sharp name means nothing without the execution to back it up. The real fire for this craft didn’t come from a television show; it is in the blood. I grew up watching my mother command the kitchen. She has been baking for twenty years, operating as an uncompromising professional for more than a decade. There were no shortcuts in her house, no skipped steps, and no accepted failures. You respected the ingredients, and you executed the technique. Just by standing beside her, absorbing that relentless discipline and the exact science of her process, the obsession took hold of me. I didn’t just learn how to fold dough; I learned the standard required to make something unforgettable.

Today, The Fifth Amendment takes that generational discipline and applies it to a modern, heavy-hitting flavor lineup. We don’t do basic, and we don’t do average. We bake unapologetic, premium profiles designed for people who know exactly what they want.

Rythm Gupta
Start an order

Help

Answers to the questions we hear most.

What does “plead the fifth” mean?

The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution says nobody can be forced to be a witness against themselves. “Pleading the fifth” means using that right to stay silent, a line made famous by courtroom dramas like Suits. For us it means one thing: when a cookie is this good, you take the last one and say nothing.

Someone took the last cookie. What now?

They should plead the fifth. That’s exactly how we began: a missing last cookie, a silent room and an episode of Suits. Read our story, then order enough that nobody has to fight over the last one.

Where is The Fifth Amendment based?

We are an artisanal, made-to-order bakery in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. Every order is baked fresh for that week and delivered to you.

How does ordering work?

Choose your flavours on the Order page, pick a delivery day and send your order through the website. We confirm by message, bake on Thursday and deliver on your day.

When can I order?

Orders open Monday to Wednesday each week. Anything placed after that goes into the following week’s bake.

When do you deliver?

We deliver on Friday and Saturday. You choose your day when you order.

How do points work?

Sign in when you order and you earn 1 point for every $10 you spend. Each point is worth $1. Once you have 10 points, you can use them to take $10 off an order, right at checkout. Points are added once your order is completed, and your balance shows in your account.

What are the weekly specials?

Every week we bake one limited cookie, one cake and one bread that are only available that week. When the week ends, they’re gone for good. We never repeat a special.

Do you have gluten-free, nut-free or sugar-free cookies?

Yes. Most of what we bake can be made gluten-free, nut-free, lactose-free, sugar-free or high-protein. Nut-free isn’t available on items made with nuts. Choose your options for each piece when you order, and tell us about any allergy in your order notes.

Can I send cookies as a gift?

Yes. Tick “This order is a gift” at checkout, add the recipient’s details and we deliver to them. You can add a handwritten note card for a small extra charge.

Do you take corporate and event orders?

Yes. We bake for offices, client gifts and events. Send us an enquiry with roughly how much you need and when.

How do I pay?

We confirm your order by message and share payment details then.

Still need help?Message us on Instagram and we will reply.

@the.fifthamendment

Loading…

Sign in with the owner account to see this page.

Contact us

Questions, corporate orders, events or celebrations. Send us a message and we’ll reply by email. No fifth pleaded here: we answer everything.

Corporate ordersGifting clients, stocking the office or catering an event? Choose “Corporate order” below and tell us roughly how much you need and when. We’ll come back with options.

You can also message us on Instagram at @the.fifthamendment.

Reviews

What our customers say about their orders.

No testimony on the record yet. Tried our cookies? Take the stand and tell us what you thought on Instagram.

Give your testimony